Secret supper clubs turn the idea of fine dining on its ear. You pay top dollar, but you won’t know where you’re going, what you’re eating or who is going to be there until a day before. And if you cancel, you’re off the list and most likely charged as well.
Yet many wait as long as a year for this type of treatment as part of the allure of the underground supper club. The consensus is that the food and experience are worth the wait and angst.
Carols Ricque and Cathy Weber tried for a full year to get a seat at the sought-after Prelude to Staplehouse (staplehouse.com). “It was terribly hard to get in,” Weber says. “We knew they sent out an email with the first 10 to respond getting seats. We would reply as quick as two minutes and that still wasn’t fast enough.” Finally, they landed two spots.
Asking about that wait in relation to the experience, Ricque says it was worth the wait and the money. “We would – and will – try again to go. It was a very cool evening and you really felt like it was something special.”
“Prelude to Staplehouse is our way to build a name for ourselves,” says Ryan Hidinger. “We very much want to be the next great thing, and not just a flash in the pan.”
Jenny Levinson, owner of Buckhead’s Souper Jenny (souperjennyatl.com), also uses her elusive events to market her restaurant. She’s been hosting events for nearly three years after reading an article about the movement in New York.“I’m an entertainer anyway,” Levinson says. “It just appealed to me as something fun to do.”
Depending on the venue, Levinson hosts 30 to 40 people at an undisclosed location. Some of her settings have been a graveyard, an art gallery and a building rooftop.
Probably the most “secret” underground dining experience is rogueApron (rogueapron.wordpress.com), which is run by a woman who will only identify herself as Lady Rogue.
“My work with rogueApron is about creating tangible opportunities for people to interact and form friendships,” Lady Rogue says. “Interpersonal connections are the foundation of a healthy local economy, and it’s my pleasure to put together events featuring Georgia-grown food.”
Lady Rogue describes her dining event as MacGyver meets Iron Chef. “We work backwards from a theme and design a menu that can be produced by volunteers without access to fancy equipment.”
Esther Andrew, founder of For Food’s Sake (forfoodssake.org), names this as her goal for serving her secret dinners, “Every event is opportunity to build awareness and create a consciousness about our food choices while getting back in touch with farmers.”
After her first time attending, Molly Baroco had this to say about her evening: “For me, it felt special – even more than going out to dinner. It’s amazing service, you get an explanation of the food and, you get to be close and see the passion of the chef – it’s something you won’t get anywhere else.”
Lady Rogue offers this motivation: “I think we all harbor the sneaking suspicion that there is something really, really cool going on just around the corner that we don’t know about. These sorts of dinners give the every person an opportunity to tap into arts, food, and performance communities that they may not intersect with otherwise.”
Bon apetite and, in this case, bonne chance, too.