The Pie Shop in Buckhead boasts a Pie Happy Hour.

Editor’s note: Yelp is a website and a mobile app – free to use – that connects users with local businesses, organizations and events. Reporter Newspapers has partnered with OTP Senior Community Manager Heidi Paruta for a monthly feature. Here are some favorite eats from Yelpers in Reporter Newspapers communities.

No matter how much turkey you’ve stuffed along your waistline, there’s always room for a sliver of sweet satisfaction. This month, in honor of Thanksgiving, we are grateful for these gooey, sweet, slices of heavenly pie.


Pie Shop

Go for Pie Happy Hour – Yes, it’s real! Try fresh pumpkin, classic apple, sweet potato with brown sugar streusel, bourbon pecan. Plus, they’ll deliver locally or ship.

3210 Roswell Rd., Suite E, Atlanta, 30305

R Thomas’ Deluxe Grill

A good choice in general for the health-conscious, offering a raw apple pie that Yelpers say is good for those going gluten-free, and described as apple-pie filling topped with nuts and berries.

1812 Peachtree Street, NW, Atlanta, 30309

Local Three

Their menu changes according to chef’s desires and available ingredients, but when you can, try their lemon pie with vanilla-blackberry jam and toasted marshmallow, or their apple butter ice cream that Yelpers call a “deconstructed” apple

3290 Northside Pkwy., Suite 120, Atlanta, 30327

Del Frisco’s Grille

Offering a Thanksgiving prix-fixe menu that includes your choice of pecan or pumpkin pie. Yelpers also savor the coconut cream pie.

3376 Peachtree Rd., NE, Atlanta, 30326


Sugar Shack

With a list of “Fall Favorites,” including pies like pumpkin, pecan, sweet potato and three types of apple, it’s a good thing these pies can be ordered in a 4″ size: One of each, please!

4058 Peachtree Rd., Brookhaven, 30319


Yelpers rave about the Deconstructed Peanut Butter Pie: graham cracker crust, chocolate sauce, peanut butter mousse and banana cream. A smart balancing act with your popcorn.

1004 Town Blvd., NE, Brookhaven, 30319

Sandy Springs

That Pie Place

Personal-sized pies, made-to-order. Tons of savory choices, but save room for dessert: Pecan, apple, cherry, “Elvis” and more.

6355 Peachtree-Dunwoody Rd., Suite 10, Sandy Springs, 30328

Cibo e Beve

Try the butter pecan gelato pie at this Italian eatery, and enjoy the chocolate-bacon crust. Yes, you read that

4969 Roswell Rd., Suite 245, Atlanta, 30342

The Brooklyn Cafe

Dubbed a hidden gem in Sandy Springs, Yelpers recommend the popular key lime pie.

220 Sandy Springs Circle, NE, Sandy Springs, 30328

Hammock’s Trading Company

Chef William is commended by Yelpers for his Lemon Icebox Pie, and it is a sight to see!

7285 Roswell Rd., Sandy Springs, 30328


Dunwoody Bakery

Certified 100 percent gluten-free bakery offering “Perfect Pies” such as pecan, pumpkin, apple and sweet potato pie.

2492 M Vernon Rd., Dunwoody, 30338

Ali’s Cookies

Honorable mention for pie-flavored cookies: Georgia peach and apple pie with toffee tastes like the “real thing.”

4511 Olde Perimeter Way, Suite 300, Atlanta, 30346